Clarifying ATO Garnishee Notices: Federal Court Rules Out Tax-Related Liability for Non-Compliant Entities

It will come as no surprise that the ATO takes overdue tax payments very seriously. Because of this, the tax office is afforded certain legal rights which enable their officers to follow up missed payments, and to collect them in full from any entity which finds themselves in arrears.

However, a recent case has set a precedent which will dictate how these claims are processed and prosecuted in the future. This case will be of particular interest to any organisation struggling with unpaid invoices, and concerned that these overdue payments will, in turn, make it difficult to submit the required tax payment on time.

In December 2018, a Federal Court heard the case of Fyna Projects Pty Ltd v DCT [2018) FCA 2041. The eventual decision means that a failure to comply with a garnishee notice from the ATO does not lead to a tax-related liability on the part of the noticee.

In the Fyna Projects Pty Ltd case, the tax payer had a tax-related liability of $770,000, and received a garnishee notice in accordance with ATO protocol. One of the parties who were in debt to the tax payer continued to make payments on this debt after the issuing of the notice. The Commissioner put it to the court that this situation was grounds for a tax-related liability on the part of the debtor, but this was rejected at a Federal level. This means that the ATO is unable to issue further garnishee notices to debtors of entities who have already been issued with these notices.

Basically, each entity is required to take responsibility for their own taxable income and their own tax bill. If a client falls into arrears on payments to your organisation, you are still required to submit payment in full when requested by the ATO. If problems arise, you will be able to raise an appeal with the ATO, although there is no guarantee that this will be successful.

Failure to comply with a garnishee notice puts an organisation at serious risk. Once the ATO garnishee notice has been served, the ATO will be able to charge interest on unpaid tax bills, as well as chase up the outstanding amounts via messages in the myGov portal, SMS communications, physical letters, and phone calls.

The ATO will also be able to freeze or discount any future tax refunds or credits in order to cover the overdue payment. The debt may be passed over to external debt collection agencies – each of which will operate their own schedule of fees in addition to the outstanding payment and accrued interest – and the ATO will be able to pursue further legal action if there is deemed to be an ongoing issue.

To learn more about how to stay compliant with the ATO’s requirements and optimise your tax payment procedures, or to discover how Pherrus’ services can help you and your business, get in touch with our expert team today. We are waiting to hear from you.

Other Insights from Pherrus

  • Accounting for Home Builders

    Accounting for Home Builders

    Could you build a structurally sound house without building plans? Impossible!  The same goes for your building business- running a successful company without proper accounting is impossible!  The construction industry contributed to 9% of all goods and services produced in Australia in 2022. This statistic highlights the industry’s significant role in the economy, meaning there’s …

    Accounting for Home Builders Read More »

  • blank

    Understanding the Changes in the NSW State Budget

    Following the announcement of the state budget for 2023-2024, you’re probably trying to get your head around the amendments that are relevant to you. Here are the main points to note: Changes to the Land Tax Exemption for a Principal Place of Residence A minimum ownership requirement is going to come into effect so that …

    Understanding the Changes in the NSW State Budget Read More »

  • Outstanding Business Tax Debt Pherrus

    Outstanding Business Tax Debt

    Last July, over 22,000 Australian businesses received warnings from the Australian Taxation Office for having tax debt over $100,000 that is more than three months late.  The ATO is on the hunt for a staggering $5 billion owed by businesses fitting this criteria. They’re setting a firm boundary to make things fair for everyone in …

    Outstanding Business Tax Debt Read More »